سلامت معنوی در پرستاران ایرانی: یک مطالعه متاآنالیز
محورهای موضوعی : قرآن و طبپروانه اصفهانی 1 , محمدعلی خمر 2 *
1 - دانشگاه علوم پزشکی زابل
2 - دانشگاه علوم پزشکی زابل
کلید واژه: سلامت معنوی, پرستاران, متاآنالیز,
چکیده مقاله :
مقدمه و هدف: سلامت معنوی یکی از ابعاد مهم سلامت در انسان و رویکردی مهم در ارتقای سلامت عمومی محسوب می شود. بنابراین، مطالعه حاضر با هدف تعیین میزان سلامت معنوی در پرستاران ایرانی انجام شد. روش بررسی: این پژوهش به روش متاآنالیز انجام شد. تمامی مطالعات مرتبط سلامت معنوی در پرستاران در پایگاه های اطلاعاتی «PubMed»، «Web of Science»، «Scopus»، «Magiran» و «SID» و موتور جستجوی «Google scholar» پایان تیر 1400 با کلیدواژه‌های مناسب جستجو شد. در این مطالعه، ناهمگونی مطالعات با استفاده از شاخص 2 I و احتمال سوگیری در انتشار توسط آزمون Egger و مدل متارگرسیون برای ارزیابی متغیرهای مظنون به ناهمگونی در سطح معناداری 05/0 بررسی شد. تعداد 16مقاله با استفاده از نرم افزار Comprehensive Meta-Analysis مورد تحلیل قرار گرفتند. یافته ها: بر مبنای مدل تصادفی، میزان سلامت معنوی در پرستاران ایرانی برابر با 81/2 ± 53/82 (04/88-02/77 : حدود اطمینان 95%) بدست آمد. میانگین و انحراف معیار سلامت مذهبی و وجودی به ترتیب 30/7±60/37 و 75/7±38/37 بود. بین حجم نمونه، سال انجام، میانگین سنی و میزان سلامت معنوی رابطه معناداری وجود داشت (05/0>P). نتیجه گیری: با توجه به یافته های پژوهش، میزان سلامت معنوی در حد مطلوب بود. بنابراین، با توجه به پایبندی کشور به ارزش های اخلاقی دستیابی به چنین نتیجه ای دور از انتظار نیست.
Introduction & Objective: Spiritual health is one of the important dimensions of human health and an important approach in promoting public health. Therefore, the present study was conducted to determine the level of spiritual health in Iranian nurses. Methods: This study was performed by meta-analysis. All related studies of nurses' spiritual health were searched in the PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus, Magiran, and SID databases and the Google Scholar search engine by the end of 22July 2021 with the appropriate keywords. In this study, the heterogeneity of studies was evaluated using index I2 and the probability of diffusion in diffusion by Egger test and Meta regression model to evaluate the variables suspected of heterogeneity at a significance level of 0.05. 16 articles were analyzed using Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software. Results: Based on a random model, the rate of spiritual health in Iranian nurses was 82.53 ± 2.81 (77.02-88.04: 95% confidence interval). The mean and standard deviation of religious and existential health were 37.60± 7.30 and 37.38±7.75, respectively. There was a significant relationship between sample size, year, mean age and spiritual health (P <0.05). Conclusion: According to the research findings, the level of spiritual health was optimal. Therefore, given the country's adherence to moral values, achieving such a result is not unexpected.
1. Azizi F. Spiritual Health a new dimension of health, Tehran Hoopa publications.2014: 10-87
2. The Bangkok charter for health promotion in a globalized world 2005, Available at: //www.vision office.com/socdev/promotion//Bangkok-charter-health-promotion.pdf.
3. Collection of Articles, An Introduction to Spiritual Health, An Inquiry into Spiritual Health, Tehran, Academy of Medical Sciences of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 2010: 6.
4. Mohagheghi M.A. Inspirational Role Models of Islamic Spiritual Health. Iranian journal of culture and health promotion. 2019; 3(2) :131-138. URL: http://ijhp.ir/article-1-162-fa.html
5. Heidari A, Yoosefee S. The Relationship between Spiritual Health and other Dimensions of Health: Presentation of a Model. Qom Univ Med Sci J. 2020; 13 (11) :68-72. URL: http://journal.muq.ac.ir/article-1-2710-fa.html
6. Abbas Ali Vashian, Ali Khalaj, Bahram Mohaghegh, Profile of Indicators of Health and Spiritual Care From the Perspective of Quran and Hadiths, Journal of Quran and Medicine. 2021;6(1): 20-31.
7. Yazdi Feyzabadi V, Seyfaddini R, GHandi M, Mehrolhasani M. The World Health Organization's Definition of Health: A Short Review of Critiques and Necessity of A Shifting Paradigm. irje. 2018; 13 :155-165.
8. Maaref M, Asadi F. Factors of achieving spiritual health from the perspective of Quran and Hadith Scientific Quarterly, Islamic Insight and Education 2017, 14(41): 1-20
9. Abbasi M, Azizi F, Shamsi Gooshki E, Naseri Rad M, Akbari Laleh M. Conceptual definition and operationalization of spiritual health. Quarterly Journal of Medical Ethics 2012, 6(20): 11-44.
10. Boivin MJ, Kirby AL, Underwood LK, Silva H. Spiritual wellbeing Scale. Trans: Hill PG, Hood RW. Measures of Religiosity. Birmingham, AL: Religious Education Press; 1999. P. 382-385.
11. Ross L, Giske T, Van Leeuwen R, Baldacchino D, McSherry W, Narayanasamy A, Jarvis P, Schep-Akkerman A. Factors contributing to student nurses'/midwives' perceived competency in spiritual care. Nurse education today. 2016; 36: 445-51.
12. Vahedian-Azimi A, Rahimi A. Concept of Spirituality: A Conventional Content Analysis. Journal of qualitative Research in Health Sciences. 2013; 2(1):11-20.
13. Balducci L. Geriatric oncology, spirituality, and palliative care. Journal of pain symptom management. 2019;57(1):171-5.
14. Blaber M, Jone J, Willis D. Spiritual care: which is the best assessment tool for palliative settings? International journal of palliative nursing. 2015;21(9):430-8.
15. Williams JA, Meltzer D, Arora V, Chung G, Curlin FA. Attention to inpatients’ religious and spiritual concerns: predictors and association with patient satisfaction. Journal of general internal medicine. 2011;26(11):1265-71.
16. MacLean CD, Susi B, Phifer N, Schultz L, Bynum D, Franco M, et al. Patient preference for physician discussion and practice of spirituality: results from a multicenter patient survey. Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2003;18(1):38-43.
17. Gall TL, Charbonneau C, Clarke NH, Grant K, Joseph A, Shouldice L. Understanding the nature and role of spirituality in relation to coping and health: A conceptual framework. Canadian psychology/psychologie Canadienne. 2005;46(2):88.
18. Clark PA, Drain M, Malone M, Safety. Addressing patients’ emotional and spiritual needs. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality. 2003;29(12):659-70.
19. Chiang Y-C, Lee H-C, Chu T-L, Han C-Y, Hsiao Y-C. The impact of nurses' spiritual health on their attitudes toward spiritual care, professional commitment, and caring. Nursing outlook. 2016;64(3):215-24.
20.Tuck I, Pullem L, Wallace D. A comparative study of the spiritual perspectives and interventions of mental health and parish nurses. Issues in Mental Health Nursing. 2001;22(6):593-605.
21. Osarrodi A, Golafshani A, Akaberi S. Relationship between spiritual well-being and quality of life in nurses. Journal of North Khorasan University of Medical Sciences. 2012;3(4):79-88. [In Persian]
22. Golipoor Khanmiri S, Khodaei A, Shirazi M, Naziri K, Medicine Ho. Evaluation of Association between Nurses' Spiritual Well-Being and Job Satisfaction in Educational-Therapeutic center Shohadaye Tabriz. Iranian Journal of Medical Ethics. 2018;11(1):220-30. [In Persian]
23. Lavasani M, Keyvanzade M, Arjmand N. Spirituality, job stress, organizational commitment, and job satisfaction among nurses in Tehran. J Contemporary Psychology. 2008;3(2):61-73. [In Persian]
24. Abdolmaleki M, Zareei A, Kanani B, Zareei S. Studying the relationship between job satisfaction and spiritual health of nurses working in the selected treatment centers of Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences. babol-iahj. 2020;5(2):50-7. [In Persian]
25.Rafiei S, Kiaiei MZ, sadeghi p, rahmati z. Role of Spiritual Health on Job Stress among Nurses A Cross-sectional Study in an Educational Hospitals of Qazvin City. jhosp. 2019;18(1):33-41. [In Persian]
26. Masoumi M, Tahmasebi R, Jalali M, Jafari F. The Study of the relationship between Job stress and spiritual health of nurses working in Intensive care ward at Bushehr Hospitals. bums-nvj. 2016;3(8):37-47. [In Persian]
27. Moeini M, Momeni T, Musarezaie A, Sharifi S. Nurses’ spiritual well-being and their perspectives on barriers to providing spiritual care. Iran J Crit Care Nurs. 2015;8(3):159-66.
28. Taghizadeganzadeh M, Shadfard Z, Montaseri MA, Zahedinia F, Karami Z, Pishgar Z. Spiritual Health in Nurses, Nursing Faculties, and Nursing Students of Jahrom University of Medical Sciences, Iran Iran Journal of Nursing. 2020;33(126, Oct 2020 ):16-27.
29. Zare A, Jahandideh S. The impact of special wards nursing spiritual well-being upon patients’ spiritual care. IJNR. 2014;9(3):30-8.
30. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and metaanalyses, the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med 2009 21;6(7):e1000097.
31. Mitton C, Adair CE, McKenzie E, Patten SB, Perry BW. Knowledge transfer and exchange:
review and synthesis of the literature. Milbank Q. 2007;85(4):729 -68.
32. Golipoor Khanmiri S, Khodaei A, Shirazi M, Naziri K. Evaluation of Association between Nurses' Spiritual Well-Being and Job Satisfaction in Educational-Therapeutic center Shohadaye Tabriz . ijme. 2018; 11 (1) :220-30.
33. Taghizadeganzadeh M, Shadfard Z, Montaseri M, Zahedinia F, Karami Z, Pishgar Z. Spiritual Health in Nurses, Nursing Faculties, and Nursing Students of Jahrom University of Medical Sciences, Iran. IJN. 2020; 33 (126) :16-27.
34. Rafiei S, Kiaiei M Z, sadeghi P, rahmati Z. Role of Spiritual Health on Job Stress among Nurses A Cross-sectional Study in an Educational Hospitals of Qazvin City. jhosp. 2019; 18 (1):33-41.
35. Assarroudi A, Jalilvand MR, Oudi D, Akaberi A. The Relationship Between Spiritual Well-Being And Life Satisfaction In The Nursing Staff Of Mashhad Hasheminezhad Hospital (2011). Modern Care, Scientific Quarterly Of Birjand Nursing And Midwifery Faculty. 2012;9(2):156-62. [In Persian]
36. 8. Atashzadeh-Shoorideh F, Abdoljabbari M, Karamkhani M, Khubestani MS, Pishgooie SA. The Relationship Between Nurses’ Spiritual Health And Their Caring Behaviors. Journal Of Reaserch On Religion & Health. 2017;3(1):5-17. [In Persian]
37. Soleimani MA, Sharif SP, Yaghoobzadeh A, Sheikhi MR, Panarello B, Win MTM. Spiritual Well-Being And Moral Distress Among Iranian Nurses. Nurs Ethics. 2019;26(4):1101-13.
38. Zareipour M, Rezaei ZM, Jafari F, Ghaderzadeh S. A Study Of The State Of Spiritual Health And Its Relation To Self-Efficacy Of Nurses. Medical Science. 2020;24(101):407-14.
39. Aghakhani N, Akbari M, Abbasi M, Naderi J, Cheraghi R, Ayremloo M, Et Al. Evaluation Of The Spiritual Health Of Cancer Patients And Their Nurses In Iran. Journal Of Nursing And Midwifery Sciences. 2016;3(3):34-9.
40. Yari JA, Siyasari A, Shirani N, Anbari M, Sargolzaei MS, Jafari J. Evaluation of the relationship between occupational stress, job satisfaction and spiritual well-being in nurses working in Razi Hospital in Saravan at 2017. Prensa Medica Argentina. 2018;104(4).
41. Ramezanzade Tabriz E, Orooji A, Bikverdi M. Investigation Clinical Competence And Its Relationship With Professional Ethics And Spiritual Health In Nurses. Health, Spirituality And Medical Ethics. 2017;4(1):2-9.
42. Jafary E, Kamarzarin H, Kordmirza E, Sefizadeh V. The Role Of Spiritual Well-Being And Coping Skills In Prediction Of Job Satisfaction In Nurses. Journal Of Clinical Nursing And Midwifery. 2015; 4. [In Persian]
43. Narimani M, Porzoor P, Atadokht A, Abbasi M. The Role Of Spiritual Well-Being And Religious Adherence In Predicting Marital Satisfaction Among Nurses. Journal Of Clinical Nursing And Midwifery. 2015;4. [In Persian]
44. Fatemi Mm, Nazari R, Safavi M, Naini Mk, Savadpour Mt. The Relationships Between Nurse’s Spirituality And Patient' S Satisfaction In The Hospitals Of To Ardabil University Of Medical Science. Medical Ethics. 2011;5(17):142-159. [In Persian]
45. Radmehr M, Rostami S, Najafi D, Dowlatkhah H, Rastegarian A, Kalani N. Investigating The Convergence Between Spiritual Health And Work Ethic Of Nurses Working In Hospitals Affiliated To Jahrom University Of Medical Sciences In 2015. Iioab Journal. 2016; 7:438-42.
46. Moghadam SR, Chegeni ME, Hafez AA. Explore the relationship among spiritual health, marital satisfaction, and demographic characteristics (age, duration of marriage, duration of employment) in Mafi hospital nurses of Susa city in 1394. Journal of Reaserch on Religion & Health. 2015;1(4):38-44.
47. Yoon, M. O. The Spiritual Well-Being And The Spiritual Nursing Care Of Nurses For Cancer Patients. The Korean Journal Of Hospice And Palliative Care. 2009; 12(2):72-79.
48. Pedrão, R. D. B., & Beresin, R. O Enfermeiro Frente À Questão Da Espiritualidade. Einstein (São Paulo). 2010; 8(1):86-91.
49. Hsiao YC, Chiang HY, Chien LY. An Exploration Of The Status Of Spiritual Health Among Nursing Students In Taiwan. Nurse Educ Today. 2010;30(5):386-92.
50. WONG WF, LUK AL. A Randomized Control Study on the Effectiveness of Holistic Health Practice Program on a Group of Baccalaureate Nursing Students. Open Nurs J. 2020 23;14(1):56- 63.
51. Hu Y, Jiao M, Li F. Effectiveness of spiritual care training to enhance spiritual health and spiritual care competency among oncology nurses. BMC palliative care. 2019;18(1):1-8.
52. Chiang YC, Lee HC, Chu TL, Han CY, Hsiao YC. The impact of nurses' spiritual health on their attitudes toward spiritual care, professional commitment, and caring. Nursing outlook. 2016 May 1;64(3):215-24
53. Jalali A, Rahmati M, Dastmozd B, Salari N, Bazrafshan MR. Relationship between spiritual health and clinical competency of nurses working in intensive care units. Journal of Health Sciences & Surveillance System. 2019 Oct 1;7(4):183-7.
54. Farahaninia M, Abbasi M, Givari A, Haghani H. Nursing Students’ Spiritual Well-Being and Their Perspectives Towards Spirituality and Spiritual Care Perspectives. IJN. 2006; 18 (44) :7-14.
55. Karren KJ, Hafen BQ, Smith NL, Frandsen KJ. Mind-body health: the effects of attitudes, emotions, and relationship. 3th Edition, Pearson: Sanfrancisco, 2006.
56. Handbook for spiritual assessment living Water's spiritual assessment program (http://www.spiritualassessment.com/manual.htm)